I can dive with sharks, cliff dive 8/10/12 meters, ride different types of roller coaster multiple times without second thoughts...
(Bungee jumping and sky diving pending)
BUT
To make me watch horror movies (recently the poltergeist), I need to know the detail story (thank you themovie spoiler.com) and hands-on-eyes 95% of the time.
Usually I'll end up being the joke among the friends for screaming or being surprise at the smallest scary parts. 😫